Best Brown Stew in Brooklyn, New York

Address: 585 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205

Kingston Bakery in Brooklyn, New York serves up generous portions of authentic Jamaican cuisine with their signature beef patties and jerk chicken being crowd favorites. The restaurant is known for their flavorful oxtail, curry goat, and rice and peas, all served with friendly hospitality and reasonable prices. Despite its modest interior, this neighborhood gem consistently delivers hearty portions of Caribbean comfort food, from their perfectly seasoned meat dishes to their fresh-baked breads and pastries.

Price Range: $

Address: 1343 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203

Bamboo Walk Caribbean Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York offers an inviting atmosphere with authentic Caribbean cuisine served in an upscale dining environment. The establishment is known for its diverse menu featuring traditional dishes like oxtail, curry goat, and jerk-seasoned proteins, complemented by attentive service and live music entertainment. The restaurant's elegant decor and warm ambiance create an ideal setting for both intimate dinners and group celebrations, though guests should be prepared for premium pricing that reflects the upscale dining experience.

Price Range: $$

Address: 671 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238

The Islands in Brooklyn, New York offers an authentic taste of Caribbean cuisine with their signature jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail dishes that locals travel from far and wide to enjoy. The cozy restaurant provides generous portions of flavorful dishes served alongside traditional sides like coconut-infused rice and peas, perfectly caramelized plantains, and fresh steamed vegetables. While the prices trend higher than typical Caribbean spots in the area, regulars appreciate the warm, homey atmosphere and consistently well-executed comfort food that keeps them coming back.

Price Range: $$

Address: 1274 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11216

Smokey Island Grille in Brooklyn, New York offers a unique self-serve experience where customers can customize their West Indian plates with a variety of traditional dishes like oxtail, curry goat, and jerk meats. The cozy establishment maintains high cleanliness standards, requiring customers to use gloves and sanitizer before serving themselves from their fresh food displays. Though the dining space is limited and parking can be challenging on Fulton Street, the restaurant compensates with an extensive menu of Caribbean classics, homemade juices, and baked goods that keeps locals coming back for more.

Price Range: $$

Address: 1501 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210

Located in McBeans, Brooklyn, New York, this authentic Caribbean eatery serves up a diverse menu featuring favorites like jerk chicken, curry goat, and their highly praised oxtails. The restaurant has built a reputation for delivering genuine West Indian flavors with generous portions, particularly noted for their perfectly seasoned rice and peas. Their menu spans from traditional ackee dishes to various curry options, making it a go-to spot for those craving a true taste of Jamaica at reasonable prices.

Price Range: $

Address: 689 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203

Peppa's in Brooklyn, New York serves up authentic Jamaican cuisine in a bustling casual atmosphere where jerk chicken is their signature specialty. The restaurant stays open late to satisfy late-night cravings with a menu featuring traditional dishes like oxtail, rice and peas, and escovitch fish. While known for generous portions and reasonable prices, the cash-only establishment can have inconsistent service and varying food quality depending on when you visit.

Price Range: $$

Address: 5814 Clarendon Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11203

Footprints Cafe in Brooklyn, New York serves up flavorful Caribbean cuisine with their signature Rasta pasta and traditional Jamaican dishes like oxtail and jerk chicken being crowd favorites. The cozy restaurant features a central bar and intimate dining space where guests can enjoy tropical cocktails like rum punch while soaking in the vibrant atmosphere accompanied by occasional live music. Though wait times can vary and parking poses a challenge, many diners praise the generous portions and reasonable prices while highlighting the attentive service from the friendly staff.

Price Range: $$

Address: 896 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225

Vee's in Brooklyn, New York offers authentic Jamaican cuisine with a menu featuring classic dishes like jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail served with traditional rice and peas. The spacious restaurant provides both dine-in and takeout options, serving up generous portions at reasonable prices that have kept locals coming back for decades. While known for their flavorful main dishes, they also offer Caribbean breakfast items like ackee and saltfish, along with various sides including plantains and festivals.

Price Range: $

Address: 376 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205

Buff Patty in Brooklyn, New York offers a diverse selection of authentic Jamaican cuisine ranging from their signature patties to hearty main dishes. The restaurant specializes in classic Caribbean comfort foods like oxtail, curry goat, and jerk chicken, all served with traditional sides like rice and peas and plantains. The casual takeout spot has built a loyal following over the years with their consistently flavorful home-style cooking, though portion sizes and prices can vary depending on the dish.

Price Range: $$

Address: 1875 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234

Located in Brooklyn, New York, Topaze offers a vibrant Caribbean dining experience with both sit-down service and a full-service bar. The restaurant serves up traditional Jamaican dishes like jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail stew, with generous portions that come paired with their signature rice and peas. While the atmosphere is festive and welcoming with live music on select nights, the service and food quality can be inconsistent, though many patrons appreciate the authentic island flavors when the kitchen is at its best.

Price Range: $$

Address: 1364 Granville Payne Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11239

Golden Krust Caribbean Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York serves up a diverse menu of Jamaican favorites, from jerk chicken and oxtail to curry goat and traditional beef patties. The casual eatery is known for its generous portions of rice and peas, mac and cheese, and various curry dishes served with traditional Caribbean sides. While the food quality can be hit-or-miss depending on the time of day, the restaurant maintains its appeal as a quick-service spot for authentic Caribbean flavors with reasonable prices.

Price Range: $

Address: 1683 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210

Located in Good Hope, Brooklyn, New York, this Jamaican restaurant offers a diverse menu featuring classic dishes like jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail served with traditional sides of rice and peas. The establishment has become known for its generous portions and authentic Caribbean seasonings, though recent reviews suggest inconsistency in food preparation and service quality. While some customers praise the flavorful curry goat and vegetarian options like chickpea stew, others note that prices have increased and the quality of signature dishes like jerk chicken and oxtail can vary from visit to visit.

Price Range: $

Address: 1695 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234

Tucked away in Blue Mountain, Brooklyn, New York, this long-standing Caribbean eatery serves up traditional Jamaican dishes with their signature jerk chicken and pork being the main attractions. The menu features a variety of island favorites including oxtail, curry goat, and rice and peas, though portion sizes and consistency can vary depending on when you visit. The casual spot has been a neighborhood staple for over two decades, offering both dine-in and takeout options with reasonable prices despite mixed reviews on service and food quality.

Price Range: $

Address: 817 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203

Located on Utica Ave in Brooklyn, New York, CJ Cafe serves up traditional Jamaican cuisine with a menu featuring classics like oxtail, curry goat, and jerk chicken. The restaurant is particularly known for their flavorful oxtail dishes and signature macaroni salad, which consistently draws praise from regulars. While seating is limited, this casual eatery maintains a steady stream of customers who come for their hearty portions of Caribbean comfort food, though wait times can be considerable during peak hours.

Price Range: $

Address: 9604 Avenue L, Brooklyn, NY 11236

Dougie's Jamaican Cuisine in Brooklyn, New York has been a long-standing fixture in the local Caribbean food scene, though recent reviews suggest inconsistent experiences. The restaurant's menu features classic Jamaican dishes like oxtail, curry goat, and jerk chicken, with their rice and peas once being a standout favorite among locals. While some customers praise certain dishes when executed well, the establishment has faced recent challenges with food quality, portion sizes, and service consistency.

Price Range: $