Best Callaloo in Brooklyn, New York

Address: 769A Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238

Natural Blend in Brooklyn, New York serves up flavorful Caribbean vegan cuisine in a welcoming atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating options. The menu features creative plant-based versions of traditional Jamaican dishes including jerk chicken, curry, and their highly praised flaky patties that keep locals coming back for more. The friendly staff provides excellent service while serving generous portions at reasonable prices, complemented by a selection of fresh smoothies and juices that perfectly round out the authentic island experience.

Price Range: $

Address: 1343 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203

Bamboo Walk Caribbean Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York offers an inviting atmosphere with authentic Caribbean cuisine served in an upscale dining environment. The establishment is known for its diverse menu featuring traditional dishes like oxtail, curry goat, and jerk-seasoned proteins, complemented by attentive service and live music entertainment. The restaurant's elegant decor and warm ambiance create an ideal setting for both intimate dinners and group celebrations, though guests should be prepared for premium pricing that reflects the upscale dining experience.

Price Range: $$

Address: 65 Kent Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11249

Kokomo Restaurant & Lounge in Brooklyn, New York offers an upscale Caribbean dining experience with a vibrant atmosphere and modern twist on traditional dishes. The stylishly decorated space features both indoor and outdoor seating areas, with a menu highlighting their popular oxtail dishes, jerk chicken, and fresh seafood options served with classic sides like rice and peas. Their creative cocktail program and attentive service complement the festive island vibe, though prices trend toward the higher end for the area.

Price Range: $$

Address: 1274 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11216

Smokey Island Grille in Brooklyn, New York offers a unique self-serve experience where customers can customize their West Indian plates with a variety of traditional dishes like oxtail, curry goat, and jerk meats. The cozy establishment maintains high cleanliness standards, requiring customers to use gloves and sanitizer before serving themselves from their fresh food displays. Though the dining space is limited and parking can be challenging on Fulton Street, the restaurant compensates with an extensive menu of Caribbean classics, homemade juices, and baked goods that keeps locals coming back for more.

Price Range: $$

Address: 62 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217

BK9 in Brooklyn, New York offers a vibrant Caribbean dining experience with a mix of traditional and modern flavors. The lively atmosphere features a stylish interior, live jazz on select nights, and both indoor and outdoor seating options for guests to enjoy. While some diners praise their signature dishes like jerk wings and oxtail, others note inconsistent execution, though the restaurant maintains its popularity as a social spot with strong cocktails and a welcoming vibe.

Price Range: $$

Address: 875 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11226

CJ Cafe in Flatbush, Brooklyn, New York, is a long-standing Jamaican eatery known for its traditional Caribbean dishes and hearty portions. The restaurant's menu features classic items like oxtail, curry goat, jerk chicken, and their widely praised macaroni salad that keeps locals coming back. While the food quality can be inconsistent at times, their stew peas and authentic Caribbean flavors have made them a neighborhood fixture for those seeking genuine Jamaican cuisine.

Price Range: $

Address: 846 Clarkson Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203

Simone's in Brooklyn, New York, is a quaint establishment serving up authentic Jamaican cuisine with their renowned oxtail and curry goat dishes stealing the spotlight. The restaurant offers generous portions of traditional favorites like jerk chicken, rice and peas, and callaloo, all prepared with genuine Caribbean flair. While the space may be modest with limited seating, the flavorful home-style cooking keeps locals coming back for more, despite occasional concerns about portion sizes and pricing.

Price Range: $$

Address: 805 Van Siclen Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207

Royal Jerk in Brooklyn, New York offers an authentic taste of Jamaica with their signature jerk chicken and pork dishes served alongside traditional sides like rice and peas. The casual takeout spot features a buffet-style setup with daily specials including oxtail, curry goat, and various seafood options prepared with Caribbean spices and flavors. While known for their flavorful jerk seasoning and homestyle cooking, the restaurant maintains a straightforward counter-service format popular with locals seeking quick Jamaican comfort food.

Address: 517 Stanley Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207

Downs River Restaurant INC in Brooklyn, New York, serves up authentic Jamaican cuisine with a menu featuring classic dishes like curry goat, jerk chicken, and various soups that locals consistently seek out. The family-run establishment provides generous portions and maintains a casual, no-frills dining atmosphere that keeps regulars coming back despite occasional service inconsistencies. While their rice and peas, patties, and curry dishes are particularly popular among customers, the restaurant is especially known for serving some of the best Jamaican soup in the neighborhood.

Price Range: $$

Address: 1482 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210

Located in Brooklyn, New York, CC's Jamaican Restaurant offers a diverse menu of authentic Caribbean cuisine featuring their standout curry goat and flavorful oxtail dishes. The restaurant consistently serves generous portions of traditional favorites like jerk chicken, rice and peas, and stew peas, with many customers praising the rich gravies and well-seasoned meats. While the food quality generally receives high marks, the customer service experience can be inconsistent, with some patrons noting warm hospitality while others encounter less attentive staff.

Price Range: $

Address: 766 E 80th St, Brooklyn, NY 11236

Nicky's Jamaican Cuisine in Brooklyn, New York, serves up authentic Caribbean flavors with generous portions of classic dishes like jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail. The restaurant offers a warm, casual atmosphere where guests can enjoy traditional Jamaican comfort food made with well-seasoned, flavorful ingredients. While the prices run slightly higher than average, the restaurant maintains a loyal following thanks to its consistently tasty food and friendly staff who provide attentive service.

Price Range: $

Address: 139A Lawrence St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Located in Sandy Beaches of Brooklyn, New York, this Caribbean eatery serves up a diverse menu of authentic Jamaican dishes including jerk chicken, oxtail, curry goat, and traditional sides like rice and peas. The restaurant specializes in both traditional breakfast items like porridge and saltfish, as well as hearty lunch specials that keep locals coming back for more. The bustling spot offers generous portions of home-style cooking with that signature Island flavor, though wait times can get lengthy during peak lunch hours.

Price Range: $$

Address: 589 New Lots Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207

Island Tropics in Brooklyn, New York serves up traditional Jamaican cuisine with a mix of classic dishes like oxtail, stew chicken, and seafood options. The casual eatery offers generous portions of Caribbean comfort food in a no-frills setting that keeps locals coming back. While the menu features staples like rice and peas, the restaurant's consistency can vary depending on the day and dish ordered.

Price Range: $

Address: 823 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225

Golden Krust Caribbean Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York offers a diverse menu of Caribbean staples, with their beef patties being a standout favorite among regular customers. The casual eatery serves up traditional dishes like jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail, alongside classics like rice and peas and plantains. While the dining atmosphere is simple with a few tables for sit-down meals, they also cater to takeout customers and offer catering services for larger events.

Price Range: $

Address: 126 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11213

Irie in Brooklyn, New York serves up an authentic taste of Jamaica with a diverse menu featuring everything from jerk chicken to curry goat. The no-frills eatery focuses on delivering hearty portions of traditional Caribbean fare, with their curry dishes and beef patties being particular standouts among regulars. While the atmosphere is casual and straightforward, the kitchen prides itself on serving flavorful comfort food that keeps locals coming back for their Caribbean food fix.

Price Range: $