Best Jamaican Restaurants in Brooklyn, New York

Address: 585 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205

Kingston Bakery in Brooklyn, New York serves up generous portions of authentic Jamaican cuisine with their signature beef patties and jerk chicken being crowd favorites. The restaurant is known for their flavorful oxtail, curry goat, and rice and peas, all served with friendly hospitality and reasonable prices. Despite its modest interior, this neighborhood gem consistently delivers hearty portions of Caribbean comfort food, from their perfectly seasoned meat dishes to their fresh-baked breads and pastries.

Price Range: $

Address: 1343 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203

Bamboo Walk Caribbean Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York offers an inviting atmosphere with authentic Caribbean cuisine served in an upscale dining environment. The establishment is known for its diverse menu featuring traditional dishes like oxtail, curry goat, and jerk-seasoned proteins, complemented by attentive service and live music entertainment. The restaurant's elegant decor and warm ambiance create an ideal setting for both intimate dinners and group celebrations, though guests should be prepared for premium pricing that reflects the upscale dining experience.

Price Range: $$

Address: 671 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238

The Islands in Brooklyn, New York offers an authentic taste of Caribbean cuisine with their signature jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail dishes that locals travel from far and wide to enjoy. The cozy restaurant provides generous portions of flavorful dishes served alongside traditional sides like coconut-infused rice and peas, perfectly caramelized plantains, and fresh steamed vegetables. While the prices trend higher than typical Caribbean spots in the area, regulars appreciate the warm, homey atmosphere and consistently well-executed comfort food that keeps them coming back.

Price Range: $$

Address: 62 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217

BK9 in Brooklyn, New York offers a vibrant Caribbean dining experience with a mix of traditional and modern flavors. The lively atmosphere features a stylish interior, live jazz on select nights, and both indoor and outdoor seating options for guests to enjoy. While some diners praise their signature dishes like jerk wings and oxtail, others note inconsistent execution, though the restaurant maintains its popularity as a social spot with strong cocktails and a welcoming vibe.

Price Range: $$

Address: 1493 Albany Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203

Roti R Us -Real Caribbean Food in Brooklyn, New York serves up authentic Caribbean dishes with their signature roti being a neighborhood staple. The establishment offers a variety of dishes including curry goat, stew chicken, and traditional doubles, though experiences can vary when it comes to portion sizes and consistency. The cozy spot maintains a mom-and-pop atmosphere, with their homestyle cooking drawing both locals and visitors looking for a taste of the Caribbean.

Price Range: $

Address: 896 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11206

Two Brothers Fish & Chips + Lucky's Jamaican & Caribbean Food in Brooklyn, New York serves up generous portions of authentic Caribbean cuisine in a welcoming atmosphere with reggae music playing in the background. The restaurant is particularly known for their tender oxtail, flavorful jerk chicken, and curry goat, all served with traditional sides like rice and peas, mac and cheese, and plantains. The friendly staff provides warm service while offering reasonably priced meals that have made this spot a neighborhood favorite for both dine-in and takeout orders.

Address: 5223 Avenue D, Brooklyn, NY 11203

JamDown in Brooklyn, New York serves up authentic Caribbean flavors in a welcoming atmosphere where gospel music fills the air and friendly staff make everyone feel at home. The menu features classics like tender oxtail, well-seasoned jerk chicken, and flavorful curry goat, all served with perfectly cooked rice and peas that keep locals coming back for more. The generous portions at reasonable prices make this spot a neighborhood favorite, where the rich gravies and authentic seasonings transport diners straight to the islands.

Price Range: $

Address: 766 E 80th St, Brooklyn, NY 11236

Nicky's Jamaican Cuisine in Brooklyn, New York, serves up authentic Caribbean flavors with generous portions of classic dishes like jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail. The restaurant offers a warm, casual atmosphere where guests can enjoy traditional Jamaican comfort food made with well-seasoned, flavorful ingredients. While the prices run slightly higher than average, the restaurant maintains a loyal following thanks to its consistently tasty food and friendly staff who provide attentive service.

Price Range: $

Address: 1936 Ralph Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234

Golden Krust in Brooklyn, New York is a Caribbean fast-food spot offering traditional Jamaican dishes like oxtail, curry goat, and their popular beef patties. The restaurant provides quick-service dining with standard portion sizes of rice and peas alongside various meat options in a casual, no-frills setting. While the establishment offers convenient takeout and delivery options, the food quality and service can be inconsistent depending on the time of visit.

Price Range: $

Address: 1887 Rockaway Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11236

Golden Krust Caribbean Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York offers a diverse menu of authentic Jamaican dishes, from their signature oxtail to curry goat served with traditional rice and peas. The establishment provides a convenient dining experience with ample free parking and a clean, welcoming atmosphere for customers seeking island flavors. While prices run slightly higher than average, their menu features classic Caribbean comfort foods like beef patties, jerk chicken, and curried dishes that aim to satisfy cravings for traditional Jamaican cuisine.

Price Range: $

Address: 5600 Clarendon Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11203

Tucked away in Island Grove, Brooklyn, New York, this cash-only Jamaican eatery serves up hearty portions of traditional Caribbean cuisine with their renowned oxtail and curry goat stealing the show. The menu features classic comfort dishes like ackee and saltfish for breakfast, along with perfectly seasoned rice and peas, fresh plantains, and spicy beef patties that keep locals coming back. While mainly a takeout spot, the reasonable prices and generous portions make it a worthwhile destination for authentic Jamaican flavors, though it's best to carry cash since that's all they accept.

Address: 1100 New Jersey Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207

Forever Jerk in Brooklyn, New York, is a no-frills roadside spot that's become renowned for its authentically smoked Jamaican fare. The restaurant specializes in perfectly seasoned jerk chicken and pork, served alongside traditional sides like rice and peas and cabbage. The casual setup features outdoor barrel smokers that fill the neighborhood with enticing aromas, drawing customers who don't mind standing in line for generously portioned, wallet-friendly Caribbean cuisine.

Price Range: $$