Best Brown Stew in Brooklyn, New York

Address: 403 Empire Blvd, Brooklyn, NY 11225

Lucky's in Brooklyn, New York serves up authentic Jamaican cuisine in a modest, no-frills setting that has become a neighborhood favorite. Their menu features well-executed classics like tender oxtail, flavorful jerk chicken, and curry goat, all served with traditional sides like rice and peas, cabbage, and sweet plantains. The restaurant has earned a reputation for generous portions at reasonable prices, with their homemade beef patties and breakfast items drawing customers from across the boroughs.

Price Range: $

Address: 9407 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11212

Located in WB, Brooklyn, New York, this cozy Jamaican spot serves up authentic island fare with standout dishes like their renowned oxtail, curry goat, and perfectly seasoned jerk chicken. Despite the humble hole-in-the-wall setting and sometimes lengthy wait times, customers keep coming back for the generous portions and wallet-friendly prices. The breakfast menu features traditional favorites like ackee and saltfish, while their homestyle lunch and dinner offerings consistently deliver authentic Caribbean flavors that transport diners straight to Jamaica.

Price Range: $

Address: 135 Kingston Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11213

Cas in Brooklyn, New York is a neighborhood Jamaican spot known for serving up hearty portions of classic Caribbean dishes like tender oxtail and grilled jerk chicken. The restaurant's signature dishes come with traditional sides like rice and peas, cabbage, and sweet fried plantains that transport diners straight to the islands. The casual eatery offers consistently flavorful food at reasonable prices, with many customers praising the tender meats and well-seasoned gravies that keep them coming back for more.

Price Range: $

Address: 98 Malcolm X Blvd, Brooklyn, NY 11221

Tucked away in Soldier, Brooklyn, New York, this no-frills Jamaican eatery serves up hearty portions of traditional Caribbean fare that transports diners straight to the islands. The menu features classics like curry goat, jerk chicken, and oxtail, all served alongside perfectly cooked rice and peas and fresh cabbage. Despite mixed reviews on some dishes, the restaurant maintains a loyal following thanks to its home-style cooking, reasonable prices, and the welcoming atmosphere that makes customers feel like they're dining at a family member's house.

Price Range: $

Address: 4122 Avenue D, Brooklyn, NY 11203

Rowe's in Brooklyn, New York serves up authentic Jamaican cuisine with a menu featuring favorites like tender oxtail, jerk chicken, and curry dishes served alongside traditional rice and peas. The cozy establishment offers both dine-in service and catering options, with friendly staff adding to the welcoming atmosphere. Their homestyle cooking brings the flavors of Jamaica to life through various seafood options, including brown stewed snapper, while their house-made ginger lemon juice provides a refreshing accompaniment to any meal.

Address: 805 Van Siclen Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207

Royal Jerk in Brooklyn, New York offers an authentic taste of Jamaica with their signature jerk chicken and pork dishes served alongside traditional sides like rice and peas. The casual takeout spot features a buffet-style setup with daily specials including oxtail, curry goat, and various seafood options prepared with Caribbean spices and flavors. While known for their flavorful jerk seasoning and homestyle cooking, the restaurant maintains a straightforward counter-service format popular with locals seeking quick Jamaican comfort food.

Address: 747 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216

Sterling Crust in Brooklyn, New York, serves up authentic Jamaican cuisine with a menu featuring favorites like jerk chicken, oxtail, and various Caribbean sides. The eatery is known for its homestyle cooking and generous portions, particularly with their rice and peas combinations and flavorful stews. The cozy spot offers both dine-in and takeout options, with friendly staff who pack meals carefully and maintain a welcoming atmosphere for customers seeking traditional island flavors.

Price Range: $$

Address: 1440 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203

Island Cz Lounge in Brooklyn, New York, offers an eclectic mix of Caribbean flavors in a vibrant setting that features both indoor dining and a comfortable porch area. The menu showcases traditional Jamaican dishes like oxtail, jerk chicken, and escovitch fish, while the bar serves up potent rum punches and tropical cocktails. The venue transforms from a casual dining spot during earlier hours to a lively nightspot with DJs spinning a mix of R&B, hip-hop, and dancehall music, complete with hookah service and space for dancing.

Price Range: $$

Address: 872 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203

Golden Krust Caribbean Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York, serves up authentic Jamaican cuisine with a menu featuring everything from spicy jerk chicken wings to traditional beef patties in flaky crusts. The casual eatery offers a variety of Caribbean staples including curry dishes, oxtail, and ackee and saltfish in a cafeteria-style setting. While the food quality can be inconsistent at times, the restaurant maintains a steady stream of customers who come for their reasonably priced island fare and classic comfort dishes.

Price Range: $

Address: 324 Livingston St, Brooklyn, NY 11217

Patty Plus in Brooklyn, New York offers a diverse menu of traditional Jamaican dishes, from beef patties and jerk chicken to oxtail and curry goat. The casual eatery serves up hearty portions of rice and peas alongside their main dishes, with various sides like plantains and cabbage rounding out the offerings. While some diners praise their beef patties and curry dishes, others have mixed feelings about the food's authenticity and consistency, making it a spot that tends to divide local opinion.

Price Range: $

Address: 685 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11206

Pine & Ginger in Brooklyn, New York offers an authentic Caribbean dining experience with a menu featuring classic Jamaican dishes like jerk chicken, oxtail, and curry goat. The vibrant spot serves up generous portions of rice and peas alongside their meats, with freshly made beef patties being a customer favorite. While some diners praise the flavorful seasonings and friendly service, the restaurant maintains a casual atmosphere complete with reggae music playing in the background.

Price Range: $

Address: 139A Lawrence St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Located in Sandy Beaches of Brooklyn, New York, this Caribbean eatery serves up a diverse menu of authentic Jamaican dishes including jerk chicken, oxtail, curry goat, and traditional sides like rice and peas. The restaurant specializes in both traditional breakfast items like porridge and saltfish, as well as hearty lunch specials that keep locals coming back for more. The bustling spot offers generous portions of home-style cooking with that signature Island flavor, though wait times can get lengthy during peak lunch hours.

Price Range: $$

Address: 4108 Farragut Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11210

Golden Krust Caribbean Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York, serves up a variety of traditional Jamaican dishes including curry goat, oxtail, and beef patties in a casual counter-service setting. The establishment maintains a clean environment with generally friendly staff, though recent reviews suggest inconsistent food quality and portion sizes. While some customers praise their authentic Caribbean flavors and fresh preparations, others note concerns about pricing and varying levels of customer service.

Price Range: $

Address: 1617 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11226

Golden Krust Caribbean Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York, serves up authentic Jamaican cuisine with their signature oxtail and beef patties being standout menu items. While prices run on the higher side, particularly for specialties like the oxtail, portions are generous and the food is consistently flavorful. The establishment maintains a straightforward counter-service setup typical of a casual Caribbean eatery, offering both dine-in and takeout options for their extensive menu of island favorites.

Price Range: $

Address: 1853 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11226

Peppas Jerk Chicken in Brooklyn, New York, is a no-frills Caribbean takeout spot nestled in the heart of Little Haiti on Nostrand Avenue. The restaurant specializes in traditional Jamaican dishes, with their signature jerk chicken and oxtail being the most talked-about items on the menu. While the establishment maintains a humble, hole-in-the-wall atmosphere, they serve generous portions at reasonable prices, making it a go-to spot for authentic Caribbean flavors in the neighborhood.

Price Range: $

Address: 3018 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11226

Real Caribbean Pot in Brooklyn, New York serves up a diverse menu of traditional Jamaican dishes including jerk chicken, oxtail, curry goat, and various seafood options served with classic sides like rice and peas, festival, and macaroni salad. The casual eatery offers generous portion sizes for their meals, making them a filling option for those seeking Caribbean comfort food in the neighborhood. While some patrons praise their fresh-made patties and homemade juices, others note inconsistency in food preparation and temperature, suggesting the experience can vary depending on timing and dish selection.

Price Range: $

Address: 9606 Avenue L, Brooklyn, NY 11236

Richard's Diner in Brooklyn, New York serves up traditional Jamaican dishes like oxtail, jerk chicken, and sweet chili salmon in a casual dining atmosphere. The menu features classic combinations of rice and peas, plantains, and various curry dishes that showcase authentic Caribbean flavors. While the food quality can be inconsistent at times, the restaurant maintains affordable prices and offers both dine-in service and takeout options for local patrons seeking island cuisine.

Price Range: $$

Address: 507 Pine St, Brooklyn, NY 11208

Jamaican Jerk House in Brooklyn, New York offers a vibrant mix of traditional Caribbean dishes with their charcoal-grilled jerk chicken being a standout favorite among locals. The menu features classic Jamaican comfort foods including curry goat, oxtail, and rice and peas, though consistency in preparation can vary depending on the day. While some customers rave about the authentic flavors and generous portions, the restaurant has received mixed feedback about their service speed and prices.

Price Range: $$

Address: 126 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11213

Irie in Brooklyn, New York serves up an authentic taste of Jamaica with a diverse menu featuring everything from jerk chicken to curry goat. The no-frills eatery focuses on delivering hearty portions of traditional Caribbean fare, with their curry dishes and beef patties being particular standouts among regulars. While the atmosphere is casual and straightforward, the kitchen prides itself on serving flavorful comfort food that keeps locals coming back for their Caribbean food fix.

Price Range: $

Address: 1848 E New York Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207

Golden Krust Caribbean Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York serves up a variety of traditional Jamaican dishes including jerk chicken, oxtail, curry goat, and their signature beef patties. The casual eatery offers both dine-in and takeout options with generous portions of rice and peas, plantains, and other Caribbean sides accompanying most meals. While known for their quick-service format and accessible location, the restaurant maintains a straightforward menu focused on familiar Caribbean comfort foods that have made them a recognizable name in the neighborhood.

Price Range: $