Best Jamaican Restaurants in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
1
Pepperpot
Address: 2215 N Doctor M.L.K. Jr Dr, Milwaukee, WI 53212
Pepperpot in Milwaukee, Wisconsin offers a vibrant Caribbean dining experience with a spacious interior featuring a bar, lounge area, and dance floor. The restaurant is known for their signature jerk chicken egg rolls and creative fusion dishes like jerk cheese curds, though consistency in food quality can vary depending on the dish. The atmosphere captures island vibes with reggae music and stylish decor, though service levels fluctuate and prices trend toward the higher end for Jamaican cuisine in the area.
Price Range: $
Known For
Not Noted
Reviews have conflicting opinions on pricing, some finding it affordable, others expensive for the portion sizes. More information would be needed to make a definitive statement.
One review mentions parking issues, implying parking is available but potentially difficult, especially during busy times.
2
Fiyahside Jamaican Cuisine
Address: 7434 W Capitol Dr, Milwaukee, WI 53216
Fiyahside Jamaican Cuisine in Milwaukee, Wisconsin is a cozy takeout spot known especially for their signature jerk chicken egg rolls and traditional Caribbean fare. The restaurant offers a variety of classic Jamaican dishes including jerk chicken, curry goat, oxtails, and rice and peas, served in a casual counter-service setting with limited waiting space. While experiences can vary, the establishment provides quick service and reasonable portions, making it a convenient option for those craving Caribbean flavors in the area.
Price Range: $$
Known For
Not Noted
Reviews are mixed on pricing. While some mention reasonable prices, others suggest prices may be increasing or that portions are too small for the price. Therefore, whether or not the prices are affordable is subjective and depends on individual customer expectations.
Several reviews mention parking challenges, either limited parking or difficulty finding parking. This implies that parking is available, but potentially limited or inconvenient.
3
Jamaican Season Island
Address: 9207 W Capitol Dr, Milwaukee, WI 53222
Jamaican Season Island in Milwaukee, Wisconsin offers a vibrant dining experience with a menu centered around traditional Caribbean fare like jerk chicken, curry dishes, and oxtail. The cozy restaurant features generous portions of flavorful dishes served alongside classic sides like rice and peas, cabbage, and plantains, though availability of certain items can vary. While opinions on service and consistency are mixed, the establishment stands out for its clean, welcoming atmosphere and authentic approach to Jamaican cuisine.
Known For
Not Noted
Several reviews describe the prices as reasonable or affordable.
Reviews mention parking, with some noting it's limited or a problem.