Best Jamaican Restaurants in Columbus, Ohio

Address: 1558 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH 43211

Island Vibes Restaurant in Columbus, Ohio serves up authentic Caribbean cuisine with their signature jerk chicken and oxtails drawing crowds from across the city. The casual eatery offers generous portions of classic dishes like curry goat, brown stew chicken, and rice and peas, accompanied by sides like cabbage and plantains that transport diners straight to Jamaica. While the parking situation can be tricky with limited street spots available, regulars say the flavorful food and reasonable prices make it worth seeking out this neighborhood gem.

Price Range: $

Address: 2444 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH 43211

Located in Columbus, Ohio, Ena's Caribbean Kitchen stands out as a vibrant spot known for its authentic Jamaican cuisine, particularly their signature jerk chicken which offers a perfect balance of heat and flavor. The menu features a variety of Caribbean staples including tender oxtail, curry goat, and fresh seafood dishes, all served with traditional sides like rice and peas, cabbage, and plantains. While the establishment maintains a casual atmosphere with limited seating, their consistent delivery of flavorful island dishes at reasonable prices has made them a beloved local fixture that draws crowds for both dine-in and takeout service.

Price Range: $

Address: 1485 S Champion Ave, Columbus, OH 43207

Lady Nay's Caribbean and Soul in Columbus, Ohio, serves up generous portions of Caribbean cuisine in a small, casual takeout setting. The menu features classic dishes like jerk chicken, oxtail, and curry chicken, accompanied by traditional sides such as rice, cabbage, and plantains. While the building may be easy to miss, customers appreciate the flavorful food and quick service, though dining in isn't an option at this neighborhood spot.

Price Range: $

Address: 1247 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201

Located in Columbus, Ohio, Jerky's Jamaican Grill offers a variety of Caribbean dishes in a casual takeout setting. The menu features traditional items like jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail, though portion sizes and consistency can vary based on the day. While some diners praise the authentic flavors and spice levels, others note that prices tend to run high for the serving sizes provided, with most main dishes ranging above $20.

Price Range: $$

Address: 2750 S Hamilton Rd, Columbus, OH 43232

Mi Yaad Jamaican Restaurant in Columbus, Ohio, offers an authentic Caribbean dining experience with a diverse menu featuring traditional dishes like curry goat, oxtail, and jerk chicken. Their signature items include flavorful rice and peas, sweet plantains, and homemade beef patties that have earned praise from local diners. The restaurant, located inside Saraga International Market, serves generous portions of home-style Jamaican cuisine with a mix of reviews on consistency but steadfast appreciation for their curry goat and authentic seasonings.

Price Range: $

Address: 1870 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43205

Caribbean Corner in Columbus, Ohio offers a casual dining experience with a menu featuring traditional Jamaican dishes like oxtail, jerk chicken, and curry goat. The hole-in-the-wall establishment serves hearty portions of rice and peas alongside their main dishes, with fried plantains available as a popular side option. While the restaurant maintains a simple, no-frills atmosphere, they aim to provide authentic Caribbean flavors to local diners looking for island cuisine.

Price Range: $

Address: 1270 Mt Vernon Ave, Columbus, OH 43203

Island Spice Cuisine in Columbus, Ohio offers a diverse menu of Caribbean comfort food ranging from oxtail to curry chicken. The casual eatery serves up traditional sides like mac and cheese, plantains, and cabbage to accompany their main dishes. While customer experiences vary, the restaurant maintains a steady flow of regulars who come particularly during early afternoon hours for their favorite comfort dishes.

Address: 2054 Jermain Dr, Columbus, OH 43219

Jamaican Mama Cuisine in Columbus, Ohio, is a cozy Caribbean eatery tucked away inside the Saraga grocery store, serving up authentic island flavors with their signature jerk chicken and tender oxtail dishes. The menu features classic Jamaican comfort food including curry goat, beef patties, and rice and peas, all seasoned with traditional Caribbean spices and served with warm hospitality. The establishment has garnered attention for their flavorful preparations and generous portions, making it a go-to spot for those craving a taste of Jamaica in central Ohio.

Price Range: $

Address: 1282 Essex Ave, Columbus, OH 43201

The Island Express Grill in Columbus, Ohio offers a diverse menu of Caribbean-inspired dishes including jerk chicken, Rasta pasta, and island-style mac and cheese. While some diners praise their Caribbean fusion take on classic dishes and generous portions, others note the restaurant's interpretation differs from traditional Caribbean preparation methods. The spot seems to hit the mark with their Rasta pasta and beef patties, though some customers suggest tempering expectations when it comes to authenticity of traditional Caribbean dishes.

Price Range: $$

Address: 323 N 20th St, Columbus, OH 43203

The Patty Shop in Columbus, Ohio is a cozy Caribbean eatery specializing in various styles of Jamaican patties and traditional dishes like jerk chicken. The casual spot offers a diverse menu of hand-crafted patties filled with everything from spicy beef to curry chicken, served alongside refreshing tropical beverages like sorrel and ginger beer. While customer experiences vary, the establishment maintains a welcoming atmosphere with friendly service and reasonable prices for those seeking a taste of Jamaica in central Ohio.

Price Range: $