Best Jamaican Restaurants in Rochester, New York

Address: 227 Genesee St, Rochester, NY 14611

Pop Style International in Rochester, New York, serves up authentic Jamaican cuisine with their renowned jerk chicken being the crown jewel of their menu. The restaurant offers generous portions of classic dishes including tender oxtails, curry goat, and perfectly seasoned rice and peas, all served with genuine Caribbean hospitality. Their made-from-scratch meals come with homestyle sides like steamed cabbage and cornbread, though early arrival is recommended as their popular items tend to sell out quickly.

Price Range: $

Address: 575 Brooks Ave, Rochester, NY 14619

People's Choice Kitchen in Rochester, New York serves up authentic Caribbean cuisine in a warm, laid-back atmosphere that feels like dining at a family member's home. The menu features their renowned jerk chicken, tender oxtails, and flavorful sides like candied yams and collard greens, all served in generous portions at reasonable prices. The welcoming owner creates a hospitable environment while dishing out homestyle Caribbean favorites that have earned this establishment recognition as a beloved local institution.

Price Range: $

Address: 1485 Dewey Ave, Rochester, NY 14615

Reggae Jamaica Restaurant & Bakery in Rochester, New York, offers an authentic taste of Caribbean cuisine with their signature jerk chicken, homemade patties, and traditional Jamaican dishes. The establishment features both a bakery and restaurant section, creating a relaxed atmosphere with Jamaican music playing in the background. Their menu includes generous portions of classic dishes like curry goat, oxtail, and various sides including cabbage, rice and peas, though it's worth noting they accept cash only for payment.

Price Range: $$

Address: 2523 E Henrietta Rd, Rochester, NY 14623

Twist Jamaican Grill in Rochester, New York, serves up generous portions of authentic Caribbean cuisine in a casual, welcoming atmosphere. The menu features standout dishes like tender oxtail, flavorful jerk chicken, and curry goat, all served with traditional sides like rice and peas, steamed cabbage, and sweet fried plantains. The friendly staff provides excellent service in this counter-style eatery, where customers can enjoy their meals at a few dine-in tables or take their heaping portions to go.

Price Range: $$

Address: 551 E Main St, Rochester, NY 14604

Everything Iz Good in Rochester, New York is a casual takeout spot serving up Jamaican staples like jerk chicken, oxtail, and curry goat in generous portions. The cozy establishment offers daily specials including traditional dishes like ackee and saltfish on Fridays, along with popular sides like rice and peas, cabbage, and plantains. Their beef patties are a customer favorite, and the restaurant maintains a steady local following despite mixed reviews about authenticity and consistency.

Price Range: $

Address: 522 E Main St, Rochester, NY 14604

Kingston Vibes in Rochester, New York, offers an inviting atmosphere with thoughtful service and a charming interior that makes diners feel right at home. The restaurant's standout dish is their tender oxtail, which comes perfectly seasoned and served with a flavorful sauce that complements their rice and beans. The affordable menu and welcoming staff have made this spot a local favorite for authentic Jamaican cuisine that keeps customers coming back for more.

Address: Closed, Rochester, NY 14609

Pan-Cart in Rochester, New York offers traditional Jamaican dishes in a casual dining setting with a menu featuring classics like oxtail, curry goat, and jerk chicken. The establishment provides generous portions of rice and peas alongside their meat-based entrées, though the execution of dishes can be inconsistent. While some diners praise their tender oxtail preparation, others note that the jerk seasoning and overall flavoring could use more authentic Caribbean flair.