Best Jamaican Restaurants in Middletown, New York
1
Yaadstyle Restaurant
Address: 156 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY 10940
Yaadstyle Restaurant in Middletown, New York serves up authentic Jamaican cuisine with a menu featuring classics like jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail stew. The casual eatery draws both locals and visitors with its generous portions of traditional dishes served alongside rice and peas, plantains, and fresh cabbage. Though service can be hit-or-miss depending on the day, the flavorful food keeps regulars coming back for Caribbean comfort fare at reasonable prices.
Price Range: $$
Known For
Not Noted
The reviews are mixed regarding affordability. While some praise the reasonable prices and generous portions, others express concern about seemingly inconsistent and high prices.
Many reviews mention ample parking as a positive aspect of the restaurant's location.
2
Sister's Island Cuisine
Address: 180 Wickham Ave, Middletown, NY 10940
Sister's Island Cuisine in Middletown, New York offers a diverse menu of Caribbean dishes featuring everything from jerk chicken to oxtail in a casual dining setting. The restaurant serves generous portions of traditional Jamaican fare including curry goat, rice and peas, and plantains, with most meals priced affordably under $20. The establishment is known for its home-style cooking and convenient takeout service, though customers are advised to arrive early for popular items like oxtail which tend to sell out quickly.
Price Range: $$
Known For
Not Noted
The reviews express differing opinions on pricing, with some describing prices as affordable and others as expensive or inconsistent.
The reviews do not provide information about parking availability at the restaurant.
3
Scotch Bonnet
Address: 1 Galleria Dr Ste 142, Middletown, NY 10941
Scotch Bonnet in Middletown, New York, offers authentic Jamaican cuisine from their bustling mall food court location, serving up classics like jerk chicken, oxtail, and beef patties. The family-owned establishment prides itself on delivering spicy, flavorful dishes with generous portions, though the rice and peas can occasionally run dry during later hours. While some diners find the prices a bit steep, the vibrant flavors and friendly service make it a convenient spot for those craving Caribbean fare during their shopping trips.
Price Range: $$
Known For
Not Noted
Some reviews mention that the food is too pricey, while others mention the prices being decent. This suggests the prices are not consistently affordable.
The restaurant is in a mall food court. Parking is available at the mall.