Best Oxtail in Amityville, New York

Address: 691 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701

Jamaica Grand Restaurant in Amityville, New York offers authentic Caribbean cuisine in a casual strip mall setting with convenient parking. The establishment serves up a variety of traditional Jamaican dishes including jerk chicken, oxtail, curry goat, and their highly praised beef patties on coco bread. While the dining space is limited with just a few stools, the generous portions and reasonable prices make it a popular choice for takeout among locals looking for a taste of the islands.

Price Range: $$

Address: 777 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701

Golden Krust Caribbean Restaurant in Amityville, New York offers a diverse menu of traditional Jamaican dishes including jerk chicken, oxtail, and their signature beef patties. The casual eatery serves up hearty portions of rice and peas, curry goat, and other island favorites, though reviews suggest the quality and consistency can be hit or miss. The establishment provides a taste of Caribbean cuisine in a no-frills setting, with friendly service from some staff members making up for what the restaurant may lack in ambiance.

Price Range: $

Address: 544 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701

Island Flavor Jerk Cuisine in Amityville, New York, offers an authentic taste of Jamaica with a diverse menu featuring everything from jerk chicken and oxtail to rasta pasta and homemade tropical drinks. The family-owned establishment has become known for their friendly service and welcoming atmosphere, where customers often praise the staff's personalized attention and warm hospitality. While some dishes like their signature jerk chicken, beef patties, and curry goat consistently receive high marks for flavor and authenticity, the restaurant also garners appreciation for its homestyle cooking and generous portions at reasonable prices.

Price Range: $$