Best Jamaican Restaurants in Newark, New Jersey

Address: 820 S Orange Ave, Newark, NJ 07106

Sun Island Plate in Newark, New Jersey offers an authentic Caribbean dining experience with their extensive menu of Jamaican favorites cooked fresh throughout the day and night. The restaurant's signature dishes include smoky jerk chicken prepared on outdoor grills, tender oxtail with rich gravy, and flavorful rasta pasta, all served with traditional sides like rice and peas, plantains, and cabbage. The casual eatery maintains a welcoming atmosphere with friendly staff who provide attentive service, though some reviewers note inconsistencies in food preparation and portion sizes.

Price Range: $$

Address: 976 18th Ave, Newark, NJ 07106

Carlos Kitchen in Newark, New Jersey serves up authentic Jamaican cuisine with a focus on traditional dishes like curry goat and cow foot soup. The restaurant's portions are generous, with hearty servings of both main dishes and traditional Caribbean sides like dumplings, yams, and bananas. The establishment offers a casual dining experience where customers can enjoy home-style Caribbean cooking at reasonable prices for the area.

Price Range: $

Address: Management Office, 10 Hill St, Newark, NJ 07102

Jamekyafoodplz in Newark, New Jersey stands out as a cherished spot for authentic Jamaican cuisine that keeps locals coming back for their flavorful dishes and signature seasonings. The establishment has earned a solid reputation for their well-executed classics like curry chicken, oxtail, and jerk specialties, all served with generous portions and exceptional attention to detail. Beyond just being a restaurant, they've also made a name for themselves in catering services and offer their popular house-made seasonings for purchase, allowing customers to bring a taste of Jamaica home with them.