Best Jamaican Restaurants in Fort Myers, Florida
1
Spice Caribbean Bar & Grille
Address: 3380 Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33916
Spice Caribbean Bar & Grille in Fort Myers, Florida, serves up authentic Jamaican cuisine with their signature jerk chicken and oxtail dishes stealing the spotlight. The family-run establishment offers generous portions of traditional favorites like curry goat, brown stew chicken, and rice and peas, all served with their famous cornbread. The casual eatery features lunch specials at wallet-friendly prices, making it a popular spot for locals seeking genuine Caribbean flavors in a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
Price Range: $
Known For
Not Noted
Multiple reviews refer to affordable prices, especially regarding the lunch specials.
The reviews do not provide information about parking availability.
2
Bahama Breeze
Address: 14701 S Tamiami Trl, Fort Myers, FL 33912
Bahama Breeze in Fort Myers, Florida, offers a vibrant Caribbean dining experience with a diverse menu featuring signature dishes like jerk chicken pasta, coconut shrimp, and tropical-inspired cocktails. The lively atmosphere includes both indoor and outdoor seating options, complete with island decor and occasional live steel drum music. Despite mixed reviews about recent menu changes and pricing, the restaurant maintains its popularity for its generous portions and Caribbean-fusion cuisine served in a casual, tropical setting.
Price Range: $$
Known For
Not Noted
Reviews are mixed regarding affordability; some find prices reasonable, while others consider them high or overpriced.
Multiple reviews confirm the availability of parking, some even mentioning ample parking.
3
Irie I Jamaican American cafe
Address: 3559 Fowler St, Fort Myers, FL 33901
Located in Fort Myers, Florida, Irie I Jamaican American cafe offers authentic Caribbean cuisine with their signature oxtail and jerk chicken dishes stealing the spotlight. The clean, inviting restaurant serves generous portions of traditional fare like curry goat, rice and peas, and cabbage sides that transport diners straight to Jamaica. While the spice levels can vary significantly between dishes, the flavorful homestyle cooking and warm island atmosphere make this spot a local favorite for Caribbean food enthusiasts.
Price Range: $$
Known For
Not Noted
Reviews are mixed; some mention high prices or being shocked by the cost, while others find the portion sizes justify the price or do not mention cost at all.
The reviews do not provide information about the availability of parking at the restaurant.
4
Island Spicez
Address: 3437 Fowler St, Fort Myers, FL 33901
Island Spicez in Fort Myers, Florida, serves up authentic Caribbean fare in a cozy, no-frills setting. Their menu features classic Jamaican dishes like jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail, accompanied by traditional sides such as rice and peas, cabbage, and their notably popular cornbread. While portion sizes are consistently generous, the restaurant has earned a reputation for its bold, flavorful seasonings and home-style cooking that keeps locals coming back for more.
Price Range: $
Known For
Not Noted
Several reviews express concerns about high prices, particularly for oxtail. Others mention good value for the portion size.
The reviews do not provide information about the parking availability at the restaurant.